This Article is About
e mail
coffee shop
Why The Revolution Will Not Be Tweeted - 2
Join 1000's of Authors at StreetArticles Today!

Why the Revolution will not be Tweeted  -  2

“Reforming Egypt in 140 Characters” and “Small Change: Why the Revolution Will Not Be Tweeted.”

The two articles in the above title, the first written by Dennis Baron and the latter by Malcolm Gladwell; both have something to say about texting/Tweeting, and Facebook.

Specifically they discuss how this new medium affects revolutions.

Baron points out, that Facebook, Twitter, Smartphones, and the Internet, were credited with the overthrow of the Egyptian government.

Baron then argues that, after Mubarak shut down the Internet, the crowd continued to grow in Tahrir Square for the next five days.

Baron then explains this mystery, saying that, “… although Americans can’t seem to survive without the constant stimulus of digital multitasking, much of the rest of the world barely notices when the cable is down” (330).

Baron then concedes that although the Internet does connect people, and is a good source for finding information, it does not replace the “sneakernet” (333).

In other words, “…when the libraries are burning, the phone lines get cut, the newspaper is shuttered, tanks surround the television station, and the Internet goes down” (333), you can still count on good old word of mouth to get the message out.

Likewise, Gladwell makes the point that revolution, real revolution, doesn’t rely on social media for success. Gladwell cites the coffee shop sit-in’s in the 1960’s.

It started with just four students, and grew into a national phenomena of some seventy thousand, “—and it happened without e-mail, texting, Facebook, or Twitter” (314).

Gladwell explains that real success, in bringing about social change depends on an organized hierarchy that operates with “military precision” (324). He also points out the importance of “… trust, and camaraderie through regular, face-to-face meetings” (324).

Gladwell goes on to say, “The evangelist of social media don’t understand this distinction; they seem to believe that a Facebook friend is the same as a real friend” (321). In other words, one shouldn’t consider CIBER friends as real friends.

In sum, then, both authors discount social networking as the catalyst of great social change.

In my opinion both Baron and Gladwell are correct.

Though I concede that Twitter and Facebook may have helped the cause in the Middle East, I think it was the singular action of that one man in Tunisia, who set himself on fire that sparked a passion for justice, which far outweighed the prevalent fear of the people.

Without that passion for change, it wouldn’t have mattered what cool gadget it was broadcast on.

In other words, the libraries will burn, and the cable will be cut, but the people will still manage to get their message out and across great divides.

It might be easier and faster than two thousand years ago, and it might not; the human spirit will prevail, not the Internet.

Street Talk

Evelyn, oh how you can write. Very nice, and nice site as well, got caught up exploring it.

  about 1 decade ago

Wow! thank you, appreciate the feedback. I confess that my only real interest in all of this is writing. I have not figured out how to make any from it so far:)

  about 1 decade ago

have you taken the 30 day challenge? It will teach you a ton of stuff if not.

  about 1 decade ago
You May Also Like
How to Use Facebook In China
I know, for Westerner in China not being able to access your Facebook account basically cripples your ability to keep in touch with the outside world. I personally think this has some very interesting implications about how western social networking is taking over our ways of communication - but that's…
By: Rodders Gillam in  News and Society  >  International   Apr 08, 2012  
  Likes: 53

No Facebook In China
As a warning to all Facebook members (is there anyone who doesn't have a Facebook account?) that are coming to China - there is no Facebook in China. It's strange for me to think that there is still a world out there that has free access to Facebook. I've been…
By: Rodders Gillam in  News and Society  >  International   May 24, 2011  
  Likes: 1

Your Trove Stealing Facebook From Itself
Earlier this week, the Social Media titan, Facebook announced Graph Search (the Beta version). The update is an extension to the search option on the portal. Currently, we are open to search only the likes, photos, and limited data. But, this option views to enhance our search experience with an…
By: intelgain34 in  Computers and Technology  >  Personal Tech   Jan 28, 2013  
  Likes: 0

Access Facebook In Vietnam on Mac
Being able to access Facebook in Vietnam on Mac is really no different than other computer operating systems. In the past, Macs and Windows PCs were a lot more different than today. By different, I mean that it was a major pain to get anything for Mac. Tech support, games,…
By: Rodders Gillam in  News and Society  >  International   Apr 08, 2012  
  Likes: 1

Proxy for Facebook In China
As a promoter for various proxies for Facebook in China, I've seen a lot of statistics over the years about who signs up for these types of services. One thing that might surprise you, is that the majority of people signing up for a proxy for Facebook in China are…
By: Rodders Gillam in  Computers and Technology   Apr 11, 2012  
  Likes: 5

Should You Delete Your Ex On Facebook After The Break Up?
The Ins And Outs Of Remaining Friends With Your Ex On Facebook When the relationship concludes, a question you may be asking yourself is what should your next step be. Should you delete your ex on Facebook? You may be asking yourself if you should completely cut your ex off…
By: Isabella Rose in  Relationships  >  Reconnecting   Aug 31, 2012  
  Likes: 5

Should I Delete Him From Facebook After The Breakup?
Breakups used to be a lot simpler than they are today. Although the process has always been heartbreaking and difficult to cope with, the advances in social media sites like Facebook have made breaking up even harder to process. It's harder than ever to just leave your ex behind you.…
By: Charlotte Jane in  Relationships  >  Conflict   Jul 26, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Get on Facebook In China And Grow Your Business
As a business owner I know how important it is to get on Facebook in China. Facebook, and social networking in general hasn't quite had the same effect on the Internet and businesses IRL. Business in China is still very much a "family and friends" deal, and advertising is very…
  Likes: 0

Deleting Your Ex On Facebook After The Break Up - Should I?
When you first break up with someone, it is normal to be completely confused about where to turn, what to say and how to act. This is compounded by the fact that you have to work out the many intricacies of Facebook too. What do you do? Should you delete…
By: Charlotte Jane in  Relationships  >  Conflict   Aug 30, 2012  
  Likes: 4

Access Facebook In Vietnam
With an updated Internet restriction policy in Vietnam, the demand to access Facebook in Vietnam has grown exponentially in the last few month. In previous years, the Facebook blocked in Vietnam was just an annoyance, something that didn't stop you from getting on your Facebook account, but just made it…
By: Rodders Gillam in  News and Society  >  International   Apr 08, 2012  
  Likes: 5

Facebook In China
Rumors are starting to fly about Facebook in China, on both Western and Chinese Internet space. However, as an American in China, I find the idea of Facebook in China laughable. Not that kind of "ha ha" funny, but in the kid of way that you laugh at a kid…
By: Rodders Gillam in  News and Society  >  International   Apr 11, 2012  
  Likes: 1

How Your Cat, Facebook And Twitter Fit Into the Online World
Cat? Facebook? Not words that you would usually string together in one sentence or phrase not so long ago, but nowadays it is a pretty much accepted that in the online world things have changed and changed in a big way. This revolution in social interaction has resulted in one…
By: Roger B Shann in  Pets  >  Cats   Jul 15, 2011  
  Likes: 3

How to Access Facebook In Vietnam
Being able to access Facebook in China is getting to be a bit of an issue these days. Sure there are lots of solutions available on the various blogs and advertising sites, but it's hard to find out what really works. One thing you have to deal with is sifting…
By: Rodders Gillam in  Computers and Technology  >  Personal Tech   Apr 08, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Reliving Your History Through the New Facebook Timeline
I am sure by now most of you social networking lovers have heard of the newest change on Facebook coming out in just weeks according to it's founder Mark Zuckerberg, Timeline. In the article above the author mentions the show "This is Your Life." Well unfortunately I am old enough…
By: April Colon in  Internet and Businesses Online  >  Social Networking   Oct 18, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Explode Your Facebook Likes In 9 Simple Steps
Do you salivate at the mouth thinking of all the people on Facebook who are so close, yet so beyond your reach? Do you see others with thousands of likes to their fanpage and wish you knew how to get facebook likes too? Over the past couple of days I've…
By: Karri Hull in  Internet and Businesses Online  >  Internet Marketing   May 20, 2012  
  Likes: 1

Article Views: 5817    Report this Article