This Article is About
orbit around the sun
strange way
solar system
Why Is Pluto Not A Planet
Join 1000's of Authors at StreetArticles Today!

Scientists have voted and if our solar system were the television show survivor then Pluto just got voted off the island. What it something that the little planet said or did? No. It simply came down to a vote among the scientific community. The short to answer to the question of, "Is Pluto a Planet?" is No, but here is how this decision came to be.

The issue was never with Pluto, now deemed a dwarf planet, rather it was an issue of definitions; specifically the definition of what a planet was and until 2006 we simply did not have a definition.

Why is Pluto not a planet? Let us count the ways. In order to be a planet a celestial body must meet certain criteria. Let's take a look at them now and answer the question, why is Pluto not a planet?

In order to be considered a planet an object must orbit the sun. Pluto certainly does this. Is Pluto a planet? No sir. In fact, if this were the only criteria then we would have thousands of planets. Let's continue on through the criteria and narrow things down.

In order to be considered a planet an object must be large enough to have formed a sphere due to its own gravity. Again, Pluto has done this. Is Pluto a planet? No sir, but we must be getting close, and we continue down the list.

Here is the kicker and the answer to why is Pluto not a planet. To be a planet an object must have cleared the neighbourhood of its own orbit around the Sun. Is Pluto a planet? No, it is not because it has not cleared its neighbourhood. There are many other objects of similar mass to Pluto in its orbit. Pluto is considered a dwarf planet.

More facts on why Pluto is not a planet.

Of the 10,000 or so members of the IAU (International Astronomical Union) only 237 voted in favour of this definition of a planet. Why is Pluto not a planet? Because 237 out of 10,000 people voted for a definition change. It seems a strange way to conduct science.

To further the argument, technically, Neptune, Jupiter, Mars and even Earth do not clear their neighbourhoods either, so they also are not planets.

What other corollary information has contributed the reasoning behind why is Pluto not a planet? Pluto's moon is about half the size of Pluto. Pluto's orbit around the Sun is highly erratic unlike the other planets and Pluto lives in an area of space called the Kuiper belt where many other objects of like size and mass exist.

Is Pluto a planet? At the end of the day, no, technically it is not considered a planet, but in the hearts of many astronomers it will always be so.

Street Talk

No comments present
You May Also Like
A Business Perspective: How Do I Fit In My Universe?
I entered Physics 101 with some fear and trepidation. How can I get through this boring subject and still get a passing grade? I can think of a thousand other classes I would rather be in! I was an Animal Science major and no business being enrolled in a Physics…
By: McK McConaha in  Business  >  Management   Jul 30, 2012  
  Likes: 5

Ladies, Thinking Of Proposing This Leap Year?
This year, 2012 is a Leap Year, and as is tradition, ladies are allowed to propose to men on the 29th February! Are you thinking of proposing to your significant other on this day? Or just thinking of being the one to pop the question? Then keep reading for some…
By: Becky2 in  Relationships  >  Engagements   Feb 27, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Must Know Astronomy - Order, Composition And Size Of Planets In Our Solar System
Astronomy, when considered in total, is a bewildering array of facts, numbers and datapoints. In fact, if you search wikipedia for the word "planet" you will get 31 pages of material. When studying any science, the urge to become overwhelmed is everpresent and with so much information, it is often…
By: jeff brunner in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   May 10, 2011  
  Likes: 2

My Astrophysics Revelations
My astrophysics revalations: The importance of Spheres and Hour Glasses in Science and Math This paper is going to include a lot of different kinds of logical theories and questions similar to "which came first the chicken or the egg," Some of which is probably not accurate, but I believe…
By: Adam10 in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Dec 08, 2011  
  Likes: 0

The Planets For Children
Children love space, so teaching the planets for children is a rewarding topic for any educator or parent. We will take a look at the eight planets that make up our solar system, find strategies to help young students and hopefully even a little more as we learn astronomy online.…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Jul 27, 2011  
  Likes: 2

How To Buy The Best Beginner Telescope
Possibly the toughest decision for any budding astronomer is make is buying their first telescope. It can feel like mission impossible with so many telescopes to choose from and telescope prices that range from reasonable to national debt levels. I like to call this phase of the hobby Mission: Purchase…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Aug 01, 2011  
  Likes: 0

The Solar System For Children
Tips to teaching the solar system for children. Few topics are more exciting for children than learning about the solar system. Likewise. few are more frustrating to teach. Hopefully I can ease your frustration and give you a few tips on teaching the solar system for children. Teaching the solar…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Jul 27, 2011  
  Likes: 3

Buzz Aldrin Announces: The Axe Apollo Space Academy
Axe bodyspray has recently announced the release of their Axe Apollo Space Academy campaign spearheaded by none other than famous moon-walker Buzz Aldrin. The APP Company, developers and publishers of the Buzz Aldrin: Portal to Space Science and Exploration mobile application have recently announced that they are updating their platform…
By: TheAPPCompany in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Feb 03, 2013  
  Likes: 0

Astronomy Software Can Help You Reach the Stars
If you are like me, you gazed up into the starry heavens at night with a sense of awe and wonder. How many worlds were out there, or quite possibly, who else was out there? I began to build an extensive collection of astronomy software and books. By the time…
By: Andrea Kaysen in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Feb 14, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Best Telescopes For Astronomy - 4 Factors to Consider When Choosing A Telescope
When looking for the best telescopes for astronomy there are several factors that you should consider when making your choice.. There are several different telescope sizes and configurations available and it can be confusing picking the one that will be best for you. Which one will be best for you…
By: Thomas Melchiore in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Jan 04, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Types Of Telescopes
Knowing the existing types of telescopes is an important step toward choosing the right one. It can become a confusing task due to the many designs available and the specific features each telescope possess. Not only is it crucial to know the basics of telescopy but it is also important…
By: Billy2 in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   May 06, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Choosing The Best Telescope For Astronomy
Picking the best telescope for astronomy is a challenging process that I'm not sure the question can even be answered. Choosing the best telescope for astronomy for you personally is an easier quest, but even so, there will be many factors to take into account. Let's consider a glimpse at…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Aug 04, 2011  
  Likes: 1

What is the Birthstone For February?
The birthstone for people born in February is amethyst. It was adopted in 1912 by an organization known as the American national association of jewelers to be the birthstone for people born in February Also experts believe that giving amethyst on your 4th, 6th and 17th wedding anniversaries brings good…
By: Varun Kumar in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Jul 28, 2012  
  Likes: 1

Was there Life Mars Was Home to
The red planet is, after earth, the most suitable planet to sustain life in our solar system. This begs the question: was there life Mars was home to? The answer is still not crystal clear but we do have a lot of facts built up at this point to support…
By: Chip Paulson in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Aug 14, 2013  
  Likes: 9

Microsoft Space Simlator - A Look Back
Way back in 1994, the Bruce Artwick Organization released a ‘game’ named Microsoft Space Simulator. It was a great off-shoot associated with Microsoft’s incredibly popular Flight Simulator and ended up being released on 3.5? floppy disk. Now when was the last time that you saw 1 of those? Since then,…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Astronomy   Aug 12, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Article Views: 2059    Report this Article