This Article is About
driver crashes
novice drivers
traffic citations
time constraints
true causes
time 2
Causes Of Teen Driver Crashes
Join 1000's of Authors at StreetArticles Today!

Causes Of Teen Driver Crashes

There is a fundamental misunderstanding of why teen drivers crash and this takes the focus off the real causes. Hint – it is NOT speeding as is commonly believed. What prompted me to write about this topic is that a short while ago a local teen died in a collision and the headline read “Speed Suspected In Teen Collision Death”. The propagation of the idea that “speed kills” takes the focus off the true reasons for teen crashes. The goal of this article is to show research on teen crashes in their first year of driving and discuss the real issues underlying the problem.

First off, lets look at what is probably the best research done on the topic, which is named “Young Novice Drivers: Careless or Clueless?” by McKnight & McKnight in 2003. This paper shows the results of the only research I know of that truly gets “under the hood” of teen crashes with the goal of understanding what really happened. They researched over 1,000 teen crashes, made a detailed analysis of each crash, and correlated the data into something that can be easily understood by everyone.

Given the headlines that we see every day, the research is eye opening. Virtually all headlines throw in the “speeding card” with a little “driving while under the influence”. Unfortunately, these are very seldom the true causes of the crash. As can be seen, speeding, defined as driving faster than the posted speed limit, was cited as a factor in only 1.3% of crashes. Let's think about this for a moment – if you read the headlines you would think it is responsible for 100% of crashes.

So, lets consider why speeding is so often cited in teen crashes:

1) Traffic citations have a set of checkboxes for the reasons behind a crash and speeding is a prominent selection. Given the time constraints of most police officers' workday, its quick to make an easy choice and check the box. A painstaking examination of a crash, similar to what was done in the McKnight research, could take a great deal of time.

2) Speeding is easy to understand and target. Vehicle speed can be measured before and after a collision by using skid marks, distance a vehicle travelled, etc. Once the speed is determined it can be compared to the posted speed limit quite easily. Anything over the speed limit and aha, we have another headline which unfortunately probably has nothing to do with the cause of the crash.

3) The true causes of the crash can be very difficult to discern and in some cases impossible to determine. For instance, the case where the driver was not scanning the road properly for dangerous situations could only be determined by having some form of eye tracker monitoring the situation. How can we tell if the driver was drowsy? Many distractions, such as reaching for a moving object, can not be found after the fact.

Now that we can see how difficult it is to figure out the true causes of crashes we need to turn to the research. This research is done by highly educated professionals whose job is to perform this type of research, determine what truly happened, and create a statistical understanding of the information that everyone can understand. The contributing factors can be seen in the excerpt from the McKnight research paper that summarizes their findings in an easy to digest table.

Given the great research done by McKnight & McKnight, lets consider the true causes of teen crashes. You will need to keep an open mind, given the sensationalist headlines, and try to understand the outcome of this incredible piece of research.

The key critical contributors for teen crashes are :

1) “Attention”, which is what the driver was focusing on at the time of the crash and was found to contribute to 23% of teen crashes. Several items fit into this category, such as attention management, avoiding distractions, etc.

2) “Search”, describes how the driver was using their vision to find dangerous driving situations. This item was cited as a contributor in 19.1% of teen crashes.

3) “Speed Adjustment” is another major contributor and cited in 20.8% of teen crashes. Please take note that this has nothing to do with speeding, which is driving faster than the posted speed limit. Speed adjustment pertains to changing the speed of the vehicle for upcoming road conditions. These include items such as sharp curves, slick surfaces, traffic conditions, road conditions, etc.

4) “Maintaining Space” is a factor in 9.8% of teen crashes and contains items like following too closely, side clearance, etc.

Together, these four items are cited as contributors in the vast majority of teen crashes. And this research should be included as part of both in-class and online drivers ed programs. Given the information it becomes obvious where we should place the emphasis for having a positive impact on saving teen lives. Of particular note is that speeding was cited in only 1.3% of these crashes. Is this what you expected? It certainly wasn't given the headlines that I have been reading!

I have read many research papers and have been involved in drivers ed for a number of years now. During that time we have trained tens of thousands of teens to drive and my observation is that the areas in McKnight are spot on. It is easy to watch new drivers and they clearly have troubles in the major areas pointed out above. If we can maintain a focus on these items in our drivers ed programs, this awareness can go a long ways to helping train safe novice drivers.

If we're going to decrease the number of teen crashes, we need to start with the understanding of why they are crashing. And to do that we need to turn to the research and not the sound bites we hear on news programs. Misunderstood sound bites, such as “Speed Kills”, contribute to the problem and everyone should be made aware of the true causes of teen crashes. And for teens that have just received their drivers permit, it is critical that they understand the potential dangerous issues on the road to becoming an experienced driver.

Street Talk

No comments present
You May Also Like
Is Grandpa Safe to Drive Anymore? When to Take the Keys
Accidents caused by elderly drivers. It's happening more and more every day. You turn on your local news, open the newspaper, or peruse the neighborhood "going ons" online. Headlines that read "Driver crashes into storefront". The gist of the story isn't what one may suspect, an alcohol or drug impaired…
By: Amy4 in  Home and Family  >  Elder Care   Jun 20, 2012  
  Likes: 2

Selecting An Online Drivers Ed Program
There are many online drivers ed programs available and doing a search will show a large number of programs ready to train teens how to drive. However, there is a wide variance in the style and type of training available for the online world. The programs range from simple presentations…
By:  in  Automotive   Apr 19, 2012  
  Likes: 1

Is Long Island the Dumping Ground Of Choice for A New Serial Killer?
Long Island, New York has earned a rather dubious reputation once again. It is unfortunately one that it has already had in the past and possibly never lost in the eyes of local police officials. Parts of the Ocean Parkway, particularly near Jones Beach, has again become the site of…
By: Reed Cambpell in  News and Society   May 16, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Help Me Calm Down! - What's Your Answer?
Within a very short time of starting a therapy business I had come across this plea several times in a very short period. Working with complementary healing it’s probably not that surprising. After discussing the options, what was surprising was how little knowledge people pay to the options available and…
By: Julian Rixon1 in  Self Improvement  >  Personal Growth   Mar 19, 2012  
  Likes: 0

How to Get A Six Pack Abs Routine Together
When it comes to abs, it is not hard to get started. You just get down to it and start training with ferocity! No, the problem lies in sticking with it. When you are tested and tempted to quit, the biggest demotivation you can have is disorganization. If you are…
By: Chip Paulson in  Health and Fitness  >  Build Muscle   Jul 20, 2013  
  Likes: 0

30 In 30 Challenge | The Thrill Of Victory, The Challenge is Complete
A challenge is something you undertake that you know going in will have some degree of difficulty with the anticipation of feeling a sense of victory upon completion. Every day is like a challenge in some way. On days you work, you can meet each task or job as if…
By: AnnMarie in  Writing and Speaking  >  Writing Articles   Mar 19, 2012  
  Likes: 8

My 9-step No-excuse Plan for Writing Articles
Have you ever sat down in front of your computer, just like you're doing now, and told yourself you'll write an article today but didn't anyway? Here is my fool-proof method on how to write articles, at least one quality article a day, every time I face the keyboard and…
By: Frances Colleen  in  Writing and Speaking  >  Writing Articles   May 11, 2011  
  Likes: 5

Are Electronic E-book Readers the Future Of Reading?
Electronic e-book readers are one of the biggest things out on the market now, they are not really new, as they have been around for a few years now, however they have recently taken off in the popularity sector. People are trading in their old books and upgrading to the…
By: Tristan Dawber in  Shopping and Product Reviews  >  Electronics   Apr 05, 2011  
  Likes: 1

Hip Hop Beat Creator – 7 Tips That Will Make Your Beats Stand Out From The Rest
As a hip hop beat creator, you have to constantly be on top of your A game with your productions, you have to constantly find new ways to set yourself apart from the crowd, but still make your beats sound intriguing enough to keep your listeners attention. It's a tough…
By: Christian1 in  Arts and Entertainment  >  Music   Dec 18, 2013  
  Likes: 4

Johnson County Public Records For Employee Screening
If you own a business in Johnson county or are in a position that entails recruiting new employees, knowing how to carry out a search of the Johnson county public records could prove very valuable to the business indeed. As you probably already know, employees can make or break a…
By: Craig Dean in  Computers and Technology  >  Computer Forensics   Mar 03, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Women's Kettlebell DVD Reviews
I've read a lot of reviews for Kettlebell DVDs recently and I decided that a lot of them were useful but all of them were lacking something. Therefore, it made sense to me to have a go at giving my own reviews. What are the other reviews lacking? I think…
By: Dom Wells in  Health and Fitness  >  Exercise   Mar 18, 2013  
  Likes: 2

Offering Your Auto
Wanting to offer your auto? Here are the distinctive ways and spots you can do as such and how each may influence the value you'll get. Also, don't miss our tips on the best time to offer your auto and what to do on the off chance that you haven't…
By: Coast Aw in  Automotive  >  Classic Cars   Jun 07, 2016  
  Likes: 2

Important Factors for Finding the Perfect Car DVD for Your Vehicle
Most car DVD systems are just dreadful. They don’t have proper balance, the bass is either too heavy or non-existent. And, they rely too heavily on sound gimmicks and mids to do the work that should be done by a properly-balanced system. Here’s what you need to know to find…
By: Silena in  Automotive  >  Classic Cars   Jun 07, 2016  
  Likes: 0

I Will Never Forget My First Time
I truly will never ever forget the first time I drove a pickup truck. Okay, so what did you think I was referring to? Well, I will never forget that either, but I am referring to a very hot summer day back in August of 1967. My grandfather had a…
By: Sal Falco in  Automotive  >  Trucks   Jun 07, 2016  
  Likes: 1

Diecast Model Cars Are My Passion
For as long as I can remember, I have been a huge fan of diecast model cars. In fact, over the years I have built up an extensive collection that includes a number of different brands of collectible model cars. It would certainly be difficult for me to choose my…
By: Edmund Brunetti in  Automotive   Jun 07, 2016  
  Likes: 0

Article Views: 3071    Report this Article