Case Study In The United Arab Emirates
Join 1000's of Authors at StreetArticles Today!

Custody laws in the United Arab Emirates are mainly transcribed in Federal Law No. 28 of the year 2005 (UAE Personal Affairs Law), and I will refer to these articles in covering the Court's discretion in family law issues. A recent custody case at our firm shows some of the reasons behind a final decision proffered by the Court of Cassation. A married couple living agreed to a mutual divorce in 2004, and filed accordingly in the Family Court.

The couple had a daughter together, and they decided to write up an agreement that gave the mother custody of the girl until she reached the age of 7 years. At such point in time, the daughter would automatically go to her father, the guardian, and he would be considered both the guardian and the custodian. When the daughter reached 7 years of age, the mother refused to hand her over to the father. The father filed a claim in court to seek the enforcement of their original agreement, by which he would gain custody of the child. The mother objected to the agreement's enforcement and sued accordingly.

After the agreement was originally made in 2004, new legislation was passed in the area of family law in 2005. The most relevant change of law was Article 156 of the Personal Affairs Law, which states that the custody of a child shall go to the mother, until 11 years of age for a boy and 13 years of age for a girl. In that same clause, the law sets out that this circumstance can change if the court determines something else is best for the child.

The mother made claims under three different laws. Under Article 110(2), in a divorce, if both parties cannot agree on the expenses for the child or the child custody, then they cannot agree to withdraw the custody itself. In accordance with Article 156, mentioned above, the mother claimed the agreement was unenforceable. Lastly, the mother claimed the agreement should be executed and the child should forcefully be taken from the father by the court, in accordance with Article 158. The Court of First Instance agreed with the mother and found that the agreement was unenforceable due to current federal legislation, and that the daughter would stay with the mother until she reached the age of 13 years. The husband successfully appealed the decision in the Court of Appeals, and was consequently awarded custody of his daughter. Following this decision, the wife appealed to the Court of Cassation, which is similar to Western society’s Supreme Court. A decision from the Court of Cassation is final and cannot be further appealed.

The final decision in the Court of Cassation upheld the judgment of the Court of Appeals, meaning the father was awarded custody of the child consistent with the agreement made by the parents in 2004. Although there was current legislation that contradicted the terms of the agreement, it is important to note that the Court held this legislation was not retroactive. According to the Court, the agreement was entered into amicably and mutually and should not be overturned. The Court found that no circumstances had changed that would render it in the child’s best interests to stay with the mother, and therefore there was no obstacle in granting the father custodianship.

This decision rendered by the Court of Cassation took into account what was best for the child in choosing to make the law non-retroactive. Though current legislation is not normally applied to agreements made before the passing of the law, the Court kept the door open to apply it retroactively if there were any changed circumstances. For instance, if in the case mentioned above, at the time the agreement was to be executed it was in the child’s best interests to stay with the mother, the Court would have applied current legislation or even extended the mother’s custodianship to past 13 years of age for the daughter. This case shows the great deal of detail of discretion awarded to Courts in deciding family law issues.

Author: Mr. Hassan Elhais is a professional Lawyer who specializes in Litigation in Dubai, United Arab Emirates.


Street Talk

No comments present
You May Also Like
Family Law - Marriage Dissolution
The dissolution of a marriage is a legal act that may not coincide with the emotional tearing asunder. Divorce is typically a painful process for all concerned. While it can take adults time to regain psychological equilibrium, there is also a threat to be involved in a court proceeding claiming…
By:  in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   Jun 02, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

About Divorce & Other Cases For A Family Law Lawyer
A divorce would probably be better settled quickly and amiably with the services of a divorce lawyer Miami legal counselor. A divorce could be a rather challenging event in the family with strong impacts on every member. Everyone is pulled into it regardless of role and preference. It is best…
By: Tim B Scott in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 28, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Custody And Parental Responsibility
Briefly explain the legal position in relation to custody/ parental responsibility following the breakdown of a relationship or marriage. Parents do not share equal parental responsibility for the child. Following a divorce, the mother will become the ‘custodian’ of young children, and the father the ‘guardian’. The custodian is obligated…
By: Hassan Elhais1 in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 21, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Divorce In the United Arab Emirates
For Muslims in the UAE, divorce is the cancelling of the valid contract of marriage between the parties. The divorce can be commenced by the husband, or by the wife if her husband gave her the right to do so (Isma’) in the marriage contract. If the wife is not…
By:  in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 19, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Parental Alienation And Reasonable Preference Of the Child In Michigan Divorce Cases
I am a divorce lawyer. My office is located in the heart of Northern Oakland County accessible to Rochester, Bloomfield and Troy as well as Clarkston, Lake Orion and Holly. Almost all of the cases I handle involve the division of property and debts. The more difficult cases to resolve…
By: Cameron Goulding in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 18, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Internet Marketing For Lawyers
Internet marketing is the revolutionary strategy that businesses and firms are utilizing to create a conspicuous setting for their enterprises. Achieving internet marketing for lawyers however is a process that not only takes planning but also a consideration of what the target market is all about and what will be…
By: jhonjack in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 12, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Handy Tips to Find the Best Lawyers In Turkey
Turkey is more than just a popular tourist destination. A lot of businessmen also come to Turkey, thanks to its booming economy. The country is known for its automotive industry, ship building, and science and technology. If you are working or living in Turkey as an immigrant and need professional…
By: Elena Korzhneva in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 12, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How to Deal With the Turkish Divorce Procedure
Due to the influx of foreign companies setting up offices in Turkey, more and more foreign nationals are coming in, and international marriages are on the rise. If you are a foreigner having problems with your marriage and thinking of getting a divorce in Turkey, hiring a lawyer is a…
By: Elena Korzhneva in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 12, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Adoption In the United Arab Emirates
Sadly a great number of children are abandoned in the United Arab Emirates each year. Most likely this is as a result of young mothers being fearful of the repercussions of bearing a child outside wedlock. It is a criminal offence in the United Arab Emirates to have a sexual…
By:  in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 08, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

About Importance Of An Attorney for Marital Property Division Agreement
Couples planning to get married nowadays are considering a prenuptial agreement that might also be known as a marital division property agreement. This type of agreement adds on to the traditional marriage vows taken on the day of the wedding where each party agrees to the disposal of property should…
By: Tim B Scott in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   May 05, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How to Search For the Best Legal Services In Turkey
Having the best lawyer in Turkey can help you handle any legal matter calmly and efficiently. The best legal services in the country will apply proven technical skills and provide strategic advice to any legal issue concerning criminal, commercial, consumer, and family law. A lawyer's services will likewise be valuable…
By: Elena Korzhneva in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   Apr 15, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

What Women Need When They Decide to Get A Divorce
Most women seeking divorce have 3 priorities: 1. Divorce Certificate 2. Custody of the children 3. Maximum Financial support and settlement 1. Divorce: After the No Objection Certificate (NOC) is received from the Family Guidance Committee in order to file the case, the claimant can proceed to court. In court,…
By:  in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   Apr 09, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Mediation Plano Tx: Protecting Your Children From Divorce Conflict
Divorce mediation Plano TX helps to protect children from experiencing the conflicts of divorce. When children witness arguments and fights between their parents, they become anxious and hurt. Their pain can be lessened when parents consciously deciding to wait to have emotional or negative discussions about divorce until their scheduled…
By: Francis S. Walsh in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   Apr 08, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Parental Rights Plano Tx: Divorce Mediation And Child Custody
Mediation is a more peaceful, less combative way to protect your parental rights Plano TX. Child custody disputes can account for some of the most unpleasant battles during a divorce, battles that are only exacerbated by warring lawyers. During mediation (or alternate dispute resolution, as it’s sometimes called) a neutral…
By: Francis S. Walsh in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   Apr 08, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Divorce Mediators Richardson Tx: Child Support, Custody And Mediation
Divorce mediators Richardson TX help couples decide on child custody arrangements. Unlike court cases, which normally involve drama that pits one parent against the other, divorce mediation involves a private discussion between spouses with an impartial third party present to guide them through the process. Mediation is suggested for divorcing…
By: Francis S. Walsh in  Legal  >  Family Law and Divorce   Apr 08, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Article Views: 799    Report this Article