How To Handle Average Performers?
Join 1000's of Authors at StreetArticles Today!

How to Handle Average Performers?

Dear Dr. Sadaqat Ali,

I head a boutique. I am struggling with two low performers and their irresponsibility for months. We upgraded our software systems several years ago, and they still do not understand how the software works. Their best performance on average lies in medium range, but there is not enough cause to terminate them. Customers don’t complain about them, but they never receive compliments either.

I have a waiting list of excellent applicants trying to get into my boutique that could elevate our team’s performance, but I feel as though I am stuck with these few who are not up to mark. How should I handle employees who just perform to meet the minimum standards?

Managing Averageness From the Desk of Dr. Sadaqat Ali:

Dear Managing Averageness I am going to suggest more work than you might have hoped. But I can assure you that if you really want to raise performance for not only these two low performers, but for the entire team, this is the route you have to take. First, let’s agree on the real problem. The issue you’re facing is not two low performers. The issue is low expectations and of course accountability. If these two team members are truly low performers and yet “there is not enough cause to terminate them,” then you are operating in a culture with mediocre norms. And if that’s true, then the work you have to do is not first and foremost with the two low performers, it is with chronically bad norms.

Over the years, as we’ve consulted with managers to work on accountability skills. We have concluded that in low performing cultures, people don’t hold others accountable. Whereas when supervisors hold others accountable it leads toward a good performing culture. However, best performing cultures are those where everyone can and does hold everyone else accountable.

The first issue to be solving here is expectation problem. If you don’t, your action against these employees will likely be seen as unfair and confusing. Over the years, we’ve had performance concerns with employees in our company as well, and while we’ve not always been perfect, we’ve tried to hold ourselves to a standard that no one’s termination will ever come as a surprise.

That’s quite a burden to put on the management of a boutique. But it is the right burden. The first goal is to set new norms. They were required to be much more specific and clear about concerns, and then follow with progressive discipline for defined periods of time. It results into three important things; first Employees learned far more from this painful process. Secondly they were far more likely to feel justly treated at the end and last but not the least departure built trust, rather than insecurity, in the rest of the organization as employees learned that there would be no “surprises” in their careers if managers had concerns about their performance.

So, how do you reset norms? How can you set a high performance standard that makes dealing with mediocrity much clearer? First thing in this regard is Confirm Standard and clear expectation. You and your employees need to have a uniform and explicit understanding about the kind of performance you expect from people. Clarity is needed on the process, steps or behaviors, and on the outcomes and results. If you want A-players in all positions, you’ll have to pay for them. You’ll have to be willing to search for them. You’ll need to invest in developing them. And you’ll need to remove those who don’t make the grade. The next step is to Go Public.

Once you have new and higher performance standard, you’ll have to go public. Let people know the bar is being raised. Let them know of any implications for jobs, for development, and any other consequences people will need to understand so there are no surprises. Acknowledge that the norms were different in the past, without sounding self-righteous and judgmental of past leadership. Frankly state how things will be going forward and why this is right for the organization and good for those involved.

Now comes the most important consideration; do not underestimate coaching and also need to replace. If someone performs below the standard, coach them—have the “content” conversation to let them know the gap between what they did and what you expected. If it continues, coach again but let them know this is now a chronic concern. People are excellent at masking ability problems. Does this employee need additional skill building? Are there any other barriers that lead to low performance? Do cater this gap.

After all these steps if it happens again, it’s time for a “relationship” conversation. At this point the person must know that termination or reassignment is an option. After this clarify the consequences and then follow through. One of the biggest concerns I had as I read your question is this statement: “for months…” This problem has gone on for too long. People often assume that to be nice they need to work on an issue for a long time. Not so.

If you’ve clarified expectations, made sure she is capable, and removed barriers, then you need to help motivate her and Motivate with natural consequences. After you have shared with her what her low performance has done to business, now you need to start a discipline process. This process often includes probation, suspension without pay, and then termination. A fair and patient process gives people the clarity, the support, and the time they need to improve. If they don’t improve, they need to be let go.

Avoiding the consequences is not positive for you, the company, or for your direct report. In conclusion, the greatest challenge you’ll face in coaching is not the individual’s performance, but your own clarity. Far too few managers/heads know how to articulate the difference between average performance and great performance. And if you can’t describe it you can’t expect it. You must do the hard work of detailing the behaviors and results you expect to see and contrasting those with typical eavrage performance. Every minute you spend more expertly articulating expectations will save you an hour in debate and resentment later.

I know this is a longer answer than you may have wanted, but it’s definitely worth the work.

Warmly, Dr Sadaqat Ali


Street Talk

No comments present
You May Also Like
How To Know What Is You Part Five
I decided to make another article because this is the most important thing you can do in your life. I’ll say it again: Know Thyself! Let find out more about you and how to know what is you. Are You Making Progress? Let’s take the business world, for example, I…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   Jun 08, 2016  
2
  Likes: 4

How To Know What Is You Part Four
A Real Life Example Personally, I keep myself fit and healthy. I go to the gym very consistently. My goal in the beginning when I started was to look like an athlete. I wanted to be jacked and completely ripped. After 6 months I was truly on my way and…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   Jun 06, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Know What Is You Part Three
Your Language As Your Guide We talked about what how knowing what is you looks like in part one. We talked about what signs you need to look after in part two. And now we are going to look deeper into the day to day language you use to look…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   Jun 03, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Know What Is You Part Two
The 4 Ways You Are Being Guided As explained in part one I am going to give you the four areas in your life where your super conscious is working with you. Helping you and giving you directions and signs to get back to your highest mission in life, if…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   Jun 04, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Know What Is You Part One
Have you ever asked yourself who you really are? What path is true for you? How do you really know what is you? I didn’t know how to answer that question at all. When I was 13 years old I wished to find someone who could just tell me who…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   Jun 03, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Stop Eating Too Much
Do you love food? Is it difficult for you to stop eating because you enjoy food too much? Has eating too much ruined the physical body that you are striving for? Is how to stop eating too much really that hard Answer, NOT AT ALL. Eating the right amount of…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 30, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Become A Master Networker
You Are Already A Master Networker You don’t need to read networking books. You don’t need networking skills. You don’t need to go to business classes and learn how to network. You don’t need to become a master networker. You are already a master networker in the field that interests…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 29, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Truly Become Successful
What I want to teach you today is the very first step to your success. 99% of the people start with the wrong step. That is why we have the 1% that is successful and the 99% that isn’t. How to truly be successful is a formula. If you start…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 28, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Make Anyone Love You
What does someone say that makes you fall in love with them? Could there be a way to actually control the love that they feel for you? Most of us think that love is something magical and it happens when it happens. However, what if you could create love and…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 28, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Free Associations Method
Free association is a technique used in psychoanalysis (and also in psycho dynamic theory) which was originally devised by Sigmund Freud out of the hypnotic method. According to that perspective, all our mind produces has an unconscious root we can reach by means of free association How We Can Apply…
By:  in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 14, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Learn To Love Yourself
How many days of the week do you tell yourself: “I love you”. How many times do your hear these words to yourself? How much time throughout the day do you take to love yourself? Most people never do it! Today I want to show you how to learn to…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 13, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Get A Raise From Your Boss
I tried looking on several high ranked websites to find one that would actually reveal how to get a raise from your boss. Unfortunately, there was not a single website that gave you the exact step by step process to help you ask for a raise the right way. I…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 13, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Deal With Conflict In A Relationship
An apology is great if it is all you got. But if you want to know how to deal with conflict in a relationship effectively then read along. This tool is very helpful if both people want to find a solution to a conflict you are having with each other.…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 13, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

How To Stop Being Your Own Worst Enemy
Do you sometimes sabotage your own success? Do you sometimes look yourself in the mirror and put yourself down? If you said yes to one of them then read along. You will learn how to stop being your own worst enemy. And learn how to become a team player in…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 13, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Managing Your State Of Mind
In this article, you will learn what goes on in your mind every time you want to take action. And how you can make your emotions work for you and manage your state efficiently. So that you can take action and succeed at any goal you want to achieve. I…
By: Benedetto in  Self Improvement  >  Mind Development   May 03, 2016  
0
  Likes: 0

Article Views: 947    Report this Article