This Article is About
internet research
internal motivation
student engagement
open question
copy paste
Internet Research - The Copy And Paste Dilemma
Join 1000's of Authors at StreetArticles Today!

What goes around, comes around!

It's funny to think that so much is made of the problems of plagiarism these days. The simplicity of copy or cut and paste from a website to an assessment task blinds us to the fact that plagiarism has been occurring for hundreds, if not thousands of years. It just takes less time these days.

Don't get me wrong here. I don't condone anyone passing off someone else's work as their own. However simply telling our students not to do it isn't enough. It's like telling a smoker to stop smoking. No internal motivation means no real chance of change. There has to be a reason. Failing that, there have to be a lot of support structures in place to encourage the desired behaviour and discourage the undesirable.

There is another important adage at work here too. If you want to effect lasting change, get them early.

One simple way of providing support for your research projects is in the way you set them out. Giving students a closed question on a particular topic begs for problems.

'Find out about the contribution of Alexander Fleming to our understanding of antibiotics' is simply asking for a cut and paste job. You'll get the answers you are after, but there will be minimal student engagement with the material. Why would they want to? Type Alexander Fleming into google, click, highlight, copy, paste and hey presto, job done.

Change that to a more open question: 'evaluate the contributions of Alexander Fleming and Howard Florey to our understanding of antibiotics' is not only higher level (Bloom's-wise) it's not as easy to do the cut and paste (unless someone else has set the same question somewhere else AND asked their students to post the answer on the wiki or unsecured school website.

Perhaps we are getting a little too paranoid here. Anyway, I did say get them early and even though the second question above provides a nice opportunity for differentiation, it probably isn't appropriate for your budding scientists. This brings me to the tabular approach to research.

My two biggest bugbears with research are avoiding plagiarism (which is teacher speak for make the students actually interact with the material) and acknowledging sources.'d have less of a problem with students passing notes or with Ali's work being copied if everyone who did it acknowledged him as the author. So to overcome this, start the research lessons off with well set out tables. One of my favourites for Year 7 students is the famous scientist one. I provide an electronic copy of the table they need to fill in. It includes the name of the scientist, birth and death, gender, nationality, scientific field of research and one quote (the allowable copy and paste) attributed to that scientist and a final column for the urls of the web pages they used for each scientist. It is very important to me that students begin early getting into the habit of acknowledging their sources directly on their work. They must complete 10 different scientists, and get 1 mark for every box which is completed. 70 in all, 12 of which they already get from one completed example and 5 additional scientists (provided they return the sheet, either by printing or email). They can choose their own final four and we make sure there are a few extra conditions, such as minimum of 2 locals (let's wave the national flag) and some attempt at gender equity and time proximity.

It is a simple assignment and the content is nowhere near as important as the technological process. Not this time. Later on, when the process is more secure, and we wean them slowly, we can head for the evaluative, analytical and creative tasks. Transitioning between interactive word docs and open ended puzzles with any number of solutions is a key part of the learning process. It would be great if students were comfortable enough in a range of software applications to look at a question and select the most appropriate tool to help them research, solve and present their work. This is definitely the goal towards which we are striving. But in the end, sometimes I'm just happy when they've done something by themselves.

Street Talk

Hmmm. It seems to me that many young people today grow up not understanding the nature of plagiarism. At the outset of my writing 'career' [which is in semi-quotes because this goes back to student days and unpaid work just to get some clips], an amateur press editor who published much of my early work suggested that authors who do get published in amateur press need to do Internet searches on their byline(s) every quarter year or so to make sure that their in-print material hasn't been posted wholesale to the Internet by someone with no rights to the material. Article spinners . . . especially those originating in places like India and China also often generate websites composed 100% of articles either spun from or even lifted wholesale from the better known content sites like Ehow. Writers who write for those sites sell all rights, so if anyone goes after the plagiarizers it is the company behind the site from which the matieral got plagiarized: but it happens on a regular basis. A friend of mine, who happens to also be the same editor, has worked in several universities as adjunct faculty over the years and confirms that her experience both as an editor and as a faculty member involve that people just have no awareness that there are legalities to copying material that someone else owns the right to. They have no concept whatsoever of Intellectual Property law. I've never found my own in-print, amateur material on the Internet, but then that editor does that every few months check herself and contacts plagiarizers informing them they must take down the material. I HAVE found paid material on the Internet that, technically, I only offered First North American serial rights to on the 'Net, but in that case I didn't mind. [Interestingly, it was from a religious wire service that should know better, but I'm not sure the Internet posting didn't come about from someone not associated with the wire service.] Others who have a professorial background have said the same thing: those who grew up in the Internet age simply don't even undrestand the concept, often, of published material belonging to rightsholders.

  about 7 years ago
You May Also Like
Why Cant I Get Pregnant? 3 Tips To Improve Your Chances Of Getting Pregnant
One of the most frequently questions women or coupes ask themselves is "Why cant I get Pregnant?" Ironically my wife and I have never had to ask this question. To be honest, out of the three children we have, only the first one was planned meticulously. The second one came…
By: Malcolm Smith in  Business   Jul 29, 2011  
  Likes: 0

New You In the New Year
How are you going to get a new you in the New Year? What are you going to do different this year than you did last year to achieve all the things you may not have? Are you headed for the gym in January to join the regulars, only to…
By: Franz Williams in  Health and Fitness  >  Weight Loss   Jan 01, 2012  
  Likes: 1

Qualities Of A Successful Affiliate Marketer – Do You Possess These 6 Important Qualities?
They're a unique breed, successful affiliate marketers, who have a specific mindset and qualities that help them rise toward the top and succeed. People come online daily with the dream of starting their own affiliate home business, but many fail simply because they don't have, or won't learn, what it…
By: Garry2 in  Internet and Businesses Online  >  Internet Marketing   Feb 13, 2012  
  Likes: 4

Improve Grades With Assistance Of English, Physics And A Level Tutors
Worried about your child’s grades at school? Then private tuition is the best solution for you to enhance the grades of your child. When you hire a private tutor for your child, it means you invest in an individual tutor who gives the full attention to your child and meets…
By: Muhammad Mazhar in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Mar 14, 2016  
  Likes: 0

Web 2 - What Impact Has it Had on Science Teaching?
Why does technology often make you feel like there is a big conspiracy and you are the last one to know? Terms like Web 2.0 are thrown around with such abandon that they are just as likely to be incorporated into the name of a very familiar product without us…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Mar 28, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Prelims for A Technical Career In Pharmacy World
There are many students who intend to pursue a career in the medicinal world without actually being a pharmacist. They want to take care of people’s health by indulging into some other aspects of pharmacy that principally requires technical knowledge and abilities. If you are also among those aspirants who…
By: Harry Millers in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Apr 26, 2014  
  Likes: 3

A Problem Shared is A Problem Halved - How to Improve Your Powerpoint Slide Show Science Lessons
I've written previously about the impact of presentations in Science lessons and lamented to excuse of technology for poor pedagogy. The reality is many of our teaching colleagues are using powerpoint to teach their classes, so how can we improve our use of this ubiquitous tool? Let me say firstly…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Science   May 12, 2011  
  Likes: 0

One Day Science Fair Projects Make Educational Middle School Homework Assignments
When you see the words "science fair projects" it is easy to think you are talking about the school gym filled with kids, parents and display boards full of pictures and graphs. But one day science fair projects can also be used as middle school homework assignments for science concepts…
By: Sue Gnagy Fegan in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Apr 13, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Easy Science Experiments for Kids Make for Great Fun at Home
Easy science experiments for kids to do at home can help make science fun and show kids and their families that science is really about what you see and experience every day. People are using scientific principles to solve problems all the time, and often do not realize it. Learning…
By: Sue Gnagy Fegan in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Apr 11, 2011  
  Likes: 2

The Need for Professional Development for Nurses In Australia
Today, there are so many complex developments and advancements in medical technology and the healthcare industry that medical professionals can never consider their learning is finished. To keep themselves abreast of the latest techniques they must necessarily keep attending workshops, medical conferences and undertake courses in professional development. Reading medical…
By: georgescifo in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Apr 18, 2012  
  Likes: 0

Multiple Metaphors - the Promise And Perils Of Technology In Science
What are your views on 'educational technology'? If there was ever a potential oxymoron, or a phrase to strike cheer or terror into the heart of a teacher, one of the nominees would surely be educational technology. Depending on the strength of your historical or mythological understandings, technology may have…
By:  in  Reference and Education  >  Science   May 13, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Science Experiments for Middle School Make Science Fairs More Fun
A middle school science fair can be a fun and interesting event for both students and parents.  Parents are generally pretty amazed at how in-depth science experiments for middle school can be and how many different ideas that are covered. Some of the concepts that are displayed and being demonstrated…
By: Sue Gnagy Fegan in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Mar 11, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Parabolic Solar Collector Making Concept
This article offers an illustrated description of a method to produce a closed parabolic trough solar energy collector box based on the elasticity of the material. What is described here is basically a manual method to make high efficiency solar collectors against very low cost, which is particularly suited for…
By: Moriala Putula in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Jul 10, 2015  
  Likes: 0

Where Einstein And Modern Physicists Fudged Up Or What the Aliens Know That Our Scientists Do Not! Part VI Black Holes Full Of Worm Holes?
In 1916 when Einstein first published his General Theory of Relativity there was a Prussian Officer, Karl Schwarzschild, a former math teacher in Germany who immediately produced an equation that showed a mass could be so dense as to never let light escape a certain critical radius. Today this radius…
By: Franklin N Williams in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Nov 17, 2011  
  Likes: 0

Where Einstein And Modern Physicists Fudged Up Or What the Aliens Know That Our Scientists Do Not
The first thing that the aliens know, if there are intergalactic aliens, is that traveling at the speed of light and greater is not only possible, but common place for them and secondly, one does not travel into the past when exceeding the speed of light. How is this possible…
By: Franklin N Williams in  Reference and Education  >  Science   Sep 02, 2011  
  Likes: 1

Article Views: 2536    Report this Article